Speculating on Indian 3G spectrum specter
The ongoing saga regarding spectrum for 3G services, use of dual technologies, etc., reminds me of 2002, the MII, TD-SCDMA and 155MHz! Read on…
Anything on the spectrum spectacle in India makes very interesting reading! It’s as though two sides fighting over a valuable possession. Worth a click!!
We have been following how the two GSM and CDMA lobbies -– COAI and AUSPI -– have been in the news over the use of mixed bands. GSM operators have constantly warned that any move to allocate spectrum in the 1900MHz band to CDMA players would adversely impact their services in the 2100MHz band. We’ve been following what the TRAI, the DoT and others have to say on all of this.
Then AUSPI informed this week that field trials conducted in Hyderabad last week had proved successful. The trial conducted by AUSPI on behalf of the Department of Telecom (DoT) claims that the co-existence of 1900 MHz and 2100 MHz is possible.
Now, we are told that defence would be vacating spectrum by end of this year and India would have 3G services by next year. Hope all disputes are settled amicably and India finally gets to see what 3G services would have to offer.
I am reminded of two things – one, the 3G license auctions in Europe, which nearly brought the wireless house down in the early 2000s, and two, an interesting development in China. I’ll dwell on the second one.
Nearly seven years ago, I happened to break the news on TD-SCDMA (Time Division-Synchronous Code-Division Multiple Access), a 3G technology being developed at that point of time by Datang Telecom and Siemens. That story link no longer exists, so I’m providing a link to another story, mentioned below.
About two and a half years later, around October 2002, the Ministry of Information Industry (MII) in China allocated a total frequency of 155MHz for TD-SCDMA! This, for an untested, untried 3G technology, in a country much larger than India, was and is still unheard of!
Makes me wonder, why did the MII give away so much of spectrum so long back to an untested 3G technology, when in India, we keep hearing reports about spectrum issues, use of dual technologies, etc. Are there lessons to be learnt from the Chinese example?
On TD-SCDMA, much later, in 2002, I also discovered not many had even heard of it in India. However, around the time I reported this 155MHz spectrum story, STING’s Robin Grewal contacted me in Delhi to find out more about this 3G technology! That was the level of interest in 3G and TD-SCDMA, and spectrum in India, at least, at that time. Things have changed since! Hopefully!!
Random Posts
- Lip-Bu Tan, president and CEO, Cadence, on global semiconductor trends
- How semicon firms can achieve high performance by simplifying business!
- Freescale in strategic partnerships with Mentor, Enea and Green Hills
- Why solar/PV is good for India? An ISA perspective!
- EDA360 unplugged with Cadence's Jaswinder Ahuja
Tag Cloud
3G 32nm AMD ARM China chip design DRAM DRAMeXchange EDA EDA tools embedded design embedded systems and software fabless fabs FPGAs Freescale Future Horizons global semiconductor industry global semiconductor market Hynix IC Insights India Indian semiconductor industry Indian solar/PV industry India Semiconductor Association India semiconductor market Intel iSuppli low-power design Malcolm Penn memory market mobile phones NAND Qimonda S. Janakiraman Samsung SEMI Semicon Semiconductors solar solar/PV solar cells Synopsys Taiwan TICategories
- 22nm
- 32nm
- 3G
- 3G spectrum
- 40nm
- 450mm
- 45nm
- 4G
- 65nm
- 802.11n
- 90nm
- A.Raja
- Aart De Geus
- Abhi Talwalkar
- Accellera
- Accenture
- access control
- Agilent
- Altera
- Aluminum electrolytic capacitors
- AMD
- AMS
- Analog Devices
- analog ICs
- analog mixed signal
- analog/RF
- analog/RF competency center
- Anand Chandrasekher
- Anil Gupta
- Ankush Oberai
- Apple
- Apple TV
- Applied Materials
- AqTronics
- ARIB
- ARM
- Asia
- Asiaworld Expo
- ASICs
- ASML
- ASPs
- ASSPs
- ASUS
- Atom
- Atom processor
- AUSPI
- automotive
- automotive electronics
- Bali
- bandwidth costs
- Bangalore
- Bangalore Nano 2007
- Bangalore serial blasts of July 25
- Bangkok
- Barack Obama
- Beagle Board
- Beceem
- Beijing Olympics
- Belliappa Kuttanna
- biometrics
- BIPV
- Blackberry
- Blade.org
- bloggers
- Blogging
- blogs
- board design
- Bosch Sensortec
- Brazil
- Brent Przybus
- Broadband
- Broadcom
- building integrated photovoltaics
- BV Naidu
- C++
- C-DoT
- C-to-Silicon Compiler
- Cadence
- Calpella
- carrier Ethernet
- CDG
- CDMA
- CDMA Development Group
- CDMA2000
- CDNLive
- CEA
- CEATEC
- cell phones
- Cellworks
- Charlie Hartley
- Chartered Semiconductor
- Chelsio
- Chi-Foon Chan
- Chimera
- China
- China Mobile
- China Sourcing Fair
- China Telecom
- China's IC industry
- China/Hong Kong
- Chinese semiconductor industry
- chip design
- chip designers
- Chip fabs
- chip industry
- chip makers
- chip market
- chip suppliers
- chips
- Christian Gregor Dieseldorff
- CIOL
- CIOs
- Cir-Q-Tech
- cloud computing
- CMOS
- CMOS camera modules
- CMP
- co-verification tools
- COAI
- communications
- components
- COMPUTEX
- Computex Taipei
- computing
- connectors
- consumer electronics
- Converge Market Insights
- convergence
- converter solution
- Core i7 processor
- Corporate Social Responsibility
- Cosmic Circuits
- Cowans LRA model
- CPF
- CPLD
- CPM
- cross-license dispute
- cross-licensing
- crystalline solar
- CSF
- CSR
- Cuil
- CustomSim
- CWG
- Cyclone III LS
- Cypress
- Cypress Semiconductor
- DAB
- DAB radios
- Dale Ford
- data center energy measurement
- Datang
- DAVIC
- DECT
- Deloitte
- Delphi FormFactor
- Denali
- Department of IT
- Derek Lidow
- design challenges
- design services
- design services in India
- design tools
- designers
- developers
- Dexcel Electronics Designs
- DFM
- DFT
- Diachi
- digital cameras
- digital factory
- digital president
- digital still cameras
- Digitimes
- DISCO
- Discovery 2009
- disk drive controllers
- display driver ICs
- display drivers
- displays
- DisplaySearch
- DLNA
- DLP
- Dr Farooq Abdullah
- Dr Gordon Moore
- Dr. Ashok Das
- Dr. Bobby Mitra
- Dr. Chi Foon-Chan
- Dr. Ganesh Natarajan
- Dr. Henning Wicht
- Dr. J. Gururaja
- Dr. Li Shi-he
- Dr. Madhusudan V. Atre
- Dr. Rajiv Jain
- Dr. Robert N. Castellano
- DRAM
- DRAM industry
- DRAM manufacturers
- DRAM market
- DRAMeXchange
- DRC/LVS
- driver ICs
- drug discovery
- DSOA
- DSPs
- DTG
- DTH
- DTV
- Dubai
- Dubai Circuit Design
- Durga Puja
- E Ink
- e-book semiconductors
- E-books
- e-passports
- ebooks
- EC
- EC ruling
- ECG-on-a-Chip
- Eclypse
- EDA
- EDA Consortium
- EDA industry
- EDA products
- EDA tools
- EDGE
- EEPROMs
- eInfochips
- Elcoteq
- Elections 2009
- electronic components
- electronic design engineers
- Electronic Design Trends
- electronic designers
- electronic equipment
- electronic paper display
- electronics
- electronics components
- Electronics Hardware
- Electronics industry
- electronics products
- electronics supply chain
- Electronics Weekly
- Electrophoretic Display
- element14
- Elpida
- embedded
- embedded applications
- embedded computing
- embedded design
- embedded designers
- embedded devices
- embedded Internet
- Embedded Internet devices
- embedded jobs
- embedded Linux
- embedded processor
- embedded software
- embedded systems
- embedded systems and software
- EmSys
- emulator
- Encounter
- Encounter Digital Implementation
- energy
- energy efficiency
- Enterprise
- enterprise technologies
- enterprise verification
- Enterprises
- epaper
- EPD
- Epson Toyocom
- EPSRC
- ESL
- Ethernet
- EU
- Europartners
- European Commission
- EV-DO Rev. A
- EVE
- Extreme Networks
- fab capacities
- fab policy
- fab spends
- Fab-Lite
- FabCity
- fabless
- fabless companies
- Fabless Semiconductor Association
- fabs
- Fabtech
- Farnell
- FDSOI
- femtocells
- First Solar
- fixed-mobile convergence
- flash memory
- flexible displays
- flexible substrates
- Flextronics
- FMC
- FOMA
- Forward Concepts
- foundries
- foundry semiconductor market
- FPDs
- FPGA
- FPGA Central
- FPGA design
- FPGA design software
- FPGA market
- FPGA Seek
- FPGAs
- France
- Freescale
- Freescale Technology Forum
- Frost
- FTF 2008
- Fujicon
- Fujitsu
- Fukuoka
- Fully Depleted Silicon On Insulator
- Future Horizons
- G1
- Galaxy Custom Designer
- Gartner
- Garuda
- Gary Shapiro
- GateRocket
- GE Healthcare
- Germany
- Gigabyte
- GK Pramod
- global chip market
- global DRAM market
- global EDA industry
- global MEMS market
- global semiconductor industry
- global semiconductor inventory
- global semiconductor manufacturing industry. global semiconductor industry
- Global semiconductor manufacturing utilization
- global semiconductor market
- Global silicon photonics market
- global solar industry
- Global Sources
- global telecom industry
- GlobalFoundries
- Google phone
- Gordon Moore
- GPS
- graphical programming
- graphical system design
- green data centers
- green electronics
- GSA
- GSM
- Gurdas Kamat
- Hanns Windele
- HardCopy IV ASICs
- hardware
- hardware policy
- hardware/software co-verification
- hardware/software co-verification solutions
- Harriet Green
- Harshad Deshpande
- HDDs
- HDMI
- healthcare
- High-definition
- high-K gate dielectric
- high-K metal gates
- high-level synthesis
- Hitachi
- HKMG
- HLS
- Hokoriku
- Hon Hai
- HSMC
- HSPA
- HTC
- Huawei
- hybrid car
- Hynix
- i-mode phones
- i-phones
- IBM
- IBM Research Labs
- IC ASPs
- IC industry
- IC Insights
- IC market
- IC Validator
- ICICI Ventures
- ICs
- IDC
- Idea Cellular
- IDF
- IDF Taiwan
- IDM
- iDTV
- IEF 2009
- IIM-Bangalore
- IISc. Bangalore
- IIT Bombay
- IIT Kharagpur
- IIT Madras
- IIT-Kanpur
- iMac
- IMS
- IMT
- InCyte Chip Estimator
- India
- India Inc.
- India Semiconductor Association
- India semiconductor market
- India's first plug-in hybrid car
- Indian 3G policy
- Indian aerospace and defense markets
- Indian branded memory market
- Indian EDA industry
- Indian electronics industry
- Indian embedded industry
- Indian fab story
- Indian IT industry
- Indian semicon policy
- Indian semiconductor industry
- Indian solar industry
- Indian solar/PV industry
- Indian telecom
- Indian telecom industry
- Indrion
- industrial segments
- Infineon
- Infineon Asiaworld Expo
- Infosys
- Ingo Guertler
- innovators
- InnovLite
- Inoueki
- integrated access devices
- Intel
- Intel Atom processor
- Intel Core 2 Duo
- Intel Developer Forum
- intelligent video surveillance system
- International Electronics Forum (IEF)
- Internet
- Internet radio stations
- Internet radios
- intranets
- Invensense
- IP creation
- IP re-use
- iPad
- iPDK
- iPhone
- iPhone 3G
- iPod
- IPs
- IPSec
- IPTV
- ISA
- ISA Excite
- ISA Vision Summit 2009
- ISE Design Suite 11
- ISI Calcutta
- Israel
- Istanbul
- iSuppli
- IT
- IT processes
- IT/OA
- Ittiam
- Ittiam Systems
- ITU
- ITU Telecom Asia
- iTV
- IVSS
- James Reinders
- Japan
- Japan chip industry
- Japan's microelectronics industry
- Jaswinder Ahuja
- Jayamahal
- Jayaram Pillai
- Jérémie Bouchaud
- JEM
- Jennifer Lo
- JETRO
- JMCC
- JNCASR
- Jobs in FPGAs and CPLDs
- Jon Cassell
- Jonney Shih
- Jordan Plofsky
- Joseph Sawicki
- K. Subramanya
- Karnataka
- KCR
- Kexin
- Khasim Syed Mohammed
- Kionix
- Kirk Skaugen
- Kishor Patil
- Klaus Maler
- Knowles
- Kochi
- Kodiak Networks
- Korea
- Korea Electronics Show
- KPIT Cummins
- KUKA
- Kyushu
- LabView
- LabView 8.6
- Lanco Solar
- Lara Chamness
- LAS-CDMA
- last mile problem
- Laurin Publishing
- LCD
- LCD monitor panels
- LCD monitors
- LCD panels
- LCD TVs
- LCDs
- LED driver ICs
- LED lighting devices
- LED lights
- LEDs
- Lexmark
- LG
- LG Telecom
- life sciences
- LinkAir
- Linux
- lithography
- Lo Wu
- logic IC market
- logic synthesis
- low power
- low-cost handsets
- low-power design
- LSI Corp.
- LSI Logic
- LTE
- LUT
- Mac OS
- Magma Design Automation
- Malcolm Penn
- malware
- Man Yue
- Manoj Gandhi
- manufacturing hub
- Marco Principato
- Market for key system semiconductors
- Marnello
- material devices
- McAfee
- MCMM
- MCUs
- MEAS
- Measurement Specialties
- Mediacart
- MediaTek
- mega fabs
- MelZoo
- memory
- memory fabs
- memory market
- MEMS
- MEMS accelerometers
- MEMS devices
- MEMS foundries
- MEMS gyroscopes
- MEMS industry
- MEMS oscillators
- MEMS sensors
- Memsic
- Mentor Graphics
- Messe Munchen
- metro area networks
- MHEG-5
- Michael J. Fister
- micro fuel cells
- microcontrollers
- Micron
- Micronics Japan
- microprocessors
- Microsoft
- MIDs
- MII
- MIII
- Mike Cowan
- Mike Splinter
- military
- military market
- Min-Sun Moon
- Minalogic
- mini fabs
- Ministry of Communication and IT
- mixed signal
- ML-PCBs
- MNRE
- Mobile
- Mobile application operating systems
- mobile broadband
- mobile computing
- mobile CPUs
- mobile devices
- mobile handheld devices
- mobile handsets
- mobile Internet
- mobile Internet devices
- mobile phone semiconductor market
- mobile phones
- mobile TV
- mobile VAS
- Mobile WiMAX
- Mobility
- Moblin
- modeling and photomask correction
- monitor panels
- Monolithic Power Systems
- monster fabs
- Moore’s Law
- Moorestown
- MosChip
- Moser Baer
- Moshe Handelsman
- Motorola
- Mouser
- MP3 players
- MPUs
- multi-core platforms
- multi-cores
- multicore programming
- multilayer PCBs
- Mumbaikars
- Munich
- Murata
- N.K. Goyal
- Nader Tadros
- Nam Hyung Kim
- NAND
- NAND flash
- NAND Flash memory
- Nanomanufacturing
- nanoscience
- Nanotechnology
- nanotubes
- Nanya
- National Semiconductor
- Near Field Communication
- NEC
- Neeraj Varma
- Nehalem
- Nehalem-EX
- net-tops
- netbooks
- Netscape
- nettops
- Networking
- NewEra
- next-generation data centers
- NFC
- NI
- NI. LabVIEW 8.5
- NIIT
- Nikon
- Nile
- Nimish Modi
- Ning
- Nintendo Wii
- Nios II processor
- Nishant Sarawgi
- NMI
- Nokia
- NOR
- notebook market
- notebooks
- NTT DoCoMo
- Nuance
- Numonyx
- nVidia
- NXP India
- OEM semiconductor design
- OEMs
- oil prices
- OLED
- OLED driver ICs
- OLEDs
- Open Handset Alliance
- Open Platforms
- Open Silicon
- Open Source
- OpenOffice
- Opera
- optical networking
- optos
- Outlook 2009
- OZ
- PA Semi
- packaging
- PADS 9.0
- Pagemaker
- Palm
- Panasonic
- Parallel computing
- parallel programming
- parallelism
- passives
- Patrice Hamard
- PCB industry
- PCB services
- PCBs
- PCI
- PDAs
- PDPs
- Perry LaForge
- PFI
- pharma
- Philips
- Philips Consumer Lifestyle
- Phoenix Solar
- phonons
- photonics
- Photonics in Asia
- Photonics Society of India
- photovoltaics
- physical designers
- Piketown
- Pine Trail
- place-and-route technology
- Playstation 3
- PLD
- PMPs
- PNDs
- polysilicon
- Poornima Shenoy
- power
- Power Forward Initiative
- power management
- Power MOSFETs
- Powerchip
- PowerPC
- PR firms
- Pradeep Chakraborty
- Pradeep Chakraborty's Blog
- Premier Farnell
- probe cards
- processors
- Procys
- product development ecosystem
- programmable devices
- ProMOS
- PTT
- PTT-over-cellular
- PTT/PoC
- PULLNANO
- push-to-talk
- PV
- Q-Cells
- Qimonda
- QorIQ multicore platform
- quad core
- Qualcomm
- Quark Express
- Quartus II software v8.0
- Quasar
- QuickPath
- Raghu Panicker
- Rahul Deokar
- Rajeev Madhavan
- Rajeev Mehtani
- Rajiv C. Mody
- Rajiv Jain
- Raju Pudota
- Raman Research Institute
- Ramkumar Subramanian
- Ramprasad Ananthaswamy
- Randy Lawson
- Ranga Prasad
- Ranjan Das
- Ravinder Gujral
- RCG
- REACH
- Real Player
- recession
- Red Hat
- Reliance
- Renasas
- Renesas
- renewable energy
- repairs
- Research Infrastructure
- retail
- retail POS kiosk
- Rev. A
- REVA
- RF
- RF CMOS
- RF MEMS switches
- RF surveillance
- RFMD
- Rich Beyer
- RISCs
- Riverbed
- roaming
- Robert Bosch
- RoHS
- RTL
- RV Colege of Engineering
- RVCE
- S. Janakiraman
- S. Uma Mahesh
- Sachin Pilot
- Samsung Electronics
- Samsung Semiconductor
- Sandeep Mehndiratta
- Sandisk
- Sanjay Deshmukh
- Sanyo
- SAP
- SAP BusinessObjects Explorer
- Sasken
- Sathya Prasad
- Saxony
- Science
- Scott Apeland
- Scott Grant
- screens
- SDR
- search engines
- Security
- security MCUs
- Seiko
- SEMATECH
- semconductors
- SEMI
- SEMI India
- Semico
- Semico Research
- Semicon
- semicon blogs
- semicon capex
- semicon fabs
- semiconductor
- semiconductor equipment
- semiconductor equipment industry
- semiconductor equipment market
- semiconductor industry
- Semiconductor Industry Association
- semiconductor IPs
- semiconductor jobs
- semiconductor manufacturing
- Semiconductor market for PMPs
- semiconductor materials
- semiconductor policy
- Semiconductors
- semiconductors and ICs update
- Semicondutors
- SemiconWorld
- SemIndia
- Sentaurus
- Shanghai
- Shanghai processor
- Sharp
- short-range wireless
- Shweta Dash
- Si-Quest
- SIA
- Siemens
- Signet Solar
- silicon photonics
- Silicon Sensing
- silicon wafers
- simulation
- single-chip design
- SK Telecom
- Skyway Software
- smart grid
- smart meters
- smartphones
- SMB strategies
- SMEs
- SoC
- social networking
- social networking for semicon professionals
- SoCs
- SoftJin
- software developers
- solar
- solar cells
- solar ecsystem
- solar energy ecosystem
- solar fabs
- solar manufacturers
- solar modules
- solar panels
- solar photovoltaics
- solar power products
- solar/PV
- Solar; Lux Research
- Solid polymer capacitors
- solid-state hard drives
- Sony
- Sony Ericsson
- South Korea
- Spain
- Spansion
- Spartan
- spectrum
- speech-recognition
- SPIRIT
- SPMT
- SRAM
- Sriram Peruvemba
- SSDs
- SSI
- ST
- ST Micro
- ST-Ericsson
- Stanley T. Myers
- StarOffice
- STBs
- Stefan de Haan
- Stephan de Haan
- Steve Svoboda
- STM
- STM8S
- STM8S105
- STM8S207
- STMicroelectronics
- storage
- STPI
- Strategic Marketing Associates
- Stratix IV FPGAs
- Subhash Bal
- Sun
- SunFab
- Suntech
- super fuel-efficient car
- SV Probe
- Symantec
- Synopsys
- System-in-Package (SiP) solutions
- system-level chips
- systems
- Systron Donner
- Taitronics
- Taiwan
- targeted design platforms
- Tata BP Solar
- Tata Teleservices
- TCAD
- TCS
- TD-SCDMA
- TD-SCDMA Forum
- TDD
- Technology
- Technopole
- Technoprobe
- Technovation 2008
- Tejas
- Telecom
- Telecom and IT
- telecom OEMs
- telecom operators
- telecommunications
- Telefonica
- telisma
- teliSpeech 10 Indian languages
- terror attack on Mumbai
- test and measurement
- Texas Instruments India
- Text 100
- TFPV
- TFTs
- Thailand
- The Information Network
- thin film
- thin film solar
- TI
- timing analysis
- Tipping Point
- Tom Feist
- Top 10
- top 10 embedded companies in India
- TPS62601
- traffic
- TRAI
- Transport
- Trilliant
- TSIA
- TSMC
- TV panels
- TwitterJobSearch
- TwitterJobSearch.com
- UIDAI
- UK
- UK-TI
- ultra mobile broadband
- UMB
- UMC
- unified power format
- union budget
- UPA
- Upendra Patel
- UPF
- USA
- USB
- V. Srikumar
- V.R. Venkatesh
- VC funding
- VCS2009
- VDAT 2010
- Venkatesh Valluri
- Venture GES
- verification
- Verilog
- VHDL
- Vic Mahadevan
- video roaming
- Videocon
- Vietman
- Vincent Ratford
- Virtex
- Virtex-5
- virtual instrumentation
- virtualization
- Virtuoso
- Vista
- Vivek Sharma
- VLSI
- VLSI conference
- VLSI Research
- VLSI Society of India
- voice
- vPro
- VSI
- VTI
- VTU
- W-CDMA
- wafer fabs
- wafer processing equipment
- Walden C. Rhines
- WAP
- WDS
- Web 2.0
- Webdesign International Festival
- WEEE
- West Bengal
- Wi-Fi
- Widgetbox
- widgets
- WIF 2008
- WIF 2010
- WiLL
- Will Strauss
- WiMAX
- WinCE
- Wind River
- wind solutions
- Wipro
- Wipro Technologies
- wired communications
- Wireless
- wireless devices
- wireless handsets
- Wireless USB
- Wireless Week
- wireless/DSP bulletin
- WirelessHART
- wireline
- WiTECK
- Workhound
- World Cup Cricket 2011
- WSTS
- WUSB
- X-Con
- Xeon 5500
- Xilinx
- yield management
- YieldManager
- Yindusoft
- Yole
- Yole Developpement
- Yukon
- Z-RAM
- ZeBu
- ZeBu-Server
- Zetex
- ZigBee
- ZTE
Blogroll
Archives
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- December 2009
- November 2009
- October 2009
- September 2009
- August 2009
- July 2009
- June 2009
- May 2009
- April 2009
- March 2009
- February 2009
- January 2009
- December 2008
- November 2008
- October 2008
- September 2008
- August 2008
- July 2008
- June 2008
- May 2008
- April 2008
- March 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007